"Peace is a daily, a weekly, a monthly process, gradually changing opinions, slowly eroding old barriers, quietly building new structures."
- John F. Kennedy
I work day-in-day-out in a medical setting, specifically one that works on research for cancer prevention and control. In the lobby of my building yesterday, I found myself in the midst of a conversation with someone who works a floor above mine. When I told him the department I was in, he said something to the extent of, "Health research- now you guys are doing the important work." He meant it in contrast to his own job, but it got me thinking. I spend time with surgical oncologists, and I also grew up in a household where health, medicine, and nutrition were the norm. Before recently, I would have agreed wholeheartedly with this young man's opinion that yes, this is undoubtedly the important work. A conversation with a friend who is studying to a be a doctor, however, has begun to shift the ways that I think about health.
Our conversation took place a few weeks ago, as we sat around a pool and talked about women and body image. A few of us ladies were lamenting the fact that eating disorders and body image disorders are so prevalent among our age group, gender, and in our cultural sphere. It takes some of the greatest young female minds and preoccupies them to the point of misery. My friend recommended that I read a chapter from a book called "Against Health: How Health Became the New Morality," specifically the chapter entitled, "Fat Panic" by Kathleen LeBesco.
In this chapter, the author looks to destabilize the notion that thin = healthy = good and that fat = unhealthy = bad.
There is considerable
scientific evidence supporting the HAES approach and
establishing that “obesity” is not the health risk it has been reported to be.
establishing that “obesity” is not the health risk it has been reported to be.
•
Weight and BMI are poor predictors of
disease and longevity.2,3,4,5,6 The
bulk of epidemiological evidence suggests that five pounds “underweight” is
more dangerous than 75 pounds “overweight.”4,7
bulk of epidemiological evidence suggests that five pounds “underweight” is
more dangerous than 75 pounds “overweight.”4,7
•
Multiple studies are suggesting that a
focus on weight as a health criterion is
often misdirected and harmful.8,9,10
often misdirected and harmful.8,9,10
•
In a study comparing the HAES model to
a diet approach, though only dieters
lost weight, both groups initially had similar improvements in metabolic fitness,
activity levels, psychological measures, and eating behaviors. After two years,
dieters had regained their weight and lost the health improvements, while the
HAES group sustained their health improvements.11
lost weight, both groups initially had similar improvements in metabolic fitness,
activity levels, psychological measures, and eating behaviors. After two years,
dieters had regained their weight and lost the health improvements, while the
HAES group sustained their health improvements.11
This link to their page lists further evidence that our current public debates around obesity are misguided and extremely harmful to everyone in our society, thin, fat, or average.
The organizations goals include:
- Accepting and respecting the diversity of body shapes and sizes
- Recognizing that health and well-being are multi-dimensional (emphasis mine), and that they include physical, social, spiritual, occupational, emotional, and intellectual aspects
- Promoting eating in a manner which balances individual nutritional needs, hunger, satiety, appetite, and pleasure
- Promoting individually appropriate, enjoyable, life-enhancing physical activity, rather than exercise that is focused on a goal of weight-loss.
Personally, these goals resonated with me deeply. They are principles that my mom, a nutritionist who worked with a range of people from the morbidly obese, pregnant women, SNAP and WIC participants, and individuals from a wide range of socially and economically diverse backgrounds, endorsed wholeheartedly. What was the point of living if you couldn't enjoy a chocolate cake? Why wake up at the break of dawn to make yourself suffer on a run when you could garden later on in the day? Make sure you're getting enough sleep! And the notorious, why the hell would I eat whole wheat pasta? It tastes like cardboard, thank you.
And this is a nutritionist.
As John F. Kennedy said, finding peace is a long, slow process, and changing opinions is a part of that. I'm curious to learn more about the links between obesity and health problems, but to take it in with a critical and discerning eye. How do you mediate between conflicting information sources? For instance, WebMD states that "someone who is 40% overweight is twice as likely to die prematurely as is a normal-weight person," while a 2006 article in the International Journal of Epidemiology states that "among the obese, little or no increase in relative risk for premature mortality is observed until one reaches BMIs in the upper 30s or higher. In other words, the vast majority of people labeled 'overweight' and 'obese' according to current definitions do not in fact face any meaningful increased risk for early death." (pg. 2)
This is an interesting contradiction that I want to research further.
Post-edit:
This American Cancer Society post, however, does maintain that weight and inactivity are definitive risk factors for cancer. As my friend Katherine pointed out, "the diets that have shifted people toward overweight unarguably also create diabetes, hypertension, heart disease, and cancer, all increasingly common problems in the US."
Food for thought.
Post-post-edit:
This Jezebel article in response to this New York Times article came out the day before I wrote this post. I didn't see these until today, but what timing!
Post-edit:
This American Cancer Society post, however, does maintain that weight and inactivity are definitive risk factors for cancer. As my friend Katherine pointed out, "the diets that have shifted people toward overweight unarguably also create diabetes, hypertension, heart disease, and cancer, all increasingly common problems in the US."
Food for thought.
Post-post-edit:
This Jezebel article in response to this New York Times article came out the day before I wrote this post. I didn't see these until today, but what timing!
No comments:
Post a Comment